Fired watchdog appeals to court
OTTAWA, CANADA - CanadaÂ’s former nuclear watchdog is seeking a judicial review into her firing by the Conservative government resulting from the shutdown of a nuclear research reactor.
Linda Keen, a long-time bureaucrat, had angered Prime Minister Stephen Harper with her handling of the Chalk River reactor shutdown that left the Conservative government scrambling and embarrassed as it coped with the shortage of medical isotopes.
The motion, submitted to the Federal Court, is the latest development in the bitter dispute between Keen and the Conservatives. She was fired as president of the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission (CNSC) when she wouldnÂ’t okay the start-up of the aging Chalk River reactor.
“By this application for judicial review, Ms. Keen is asking the Federal Court to declare that she was unlawfully removed as president and that the November 2005 Order in Council, which reappointed her as president, remains in full force and effect,” said Ottawa lawyer Allan O’Brien.
Keen, who remains on the CNSC board, recently told ParliamentÂ’s natural resources committee that it is not the job of a nuclear regulator to ensure the production of isotopes but rather that the public is protected from nuclear accidents.
The reactor was voluntarily taken out of service by Atomic Energy Canada Ltd. because of ongoing safety concerns.
The Harper government brought in emergency legislation to override KeenÂ’s safety warnings and restart the reactor in mid-December. The CNSC is an independent quasi-judicial body meant to work at armÂ’s length from the government.
It was a month later that Natural Resources Minister Gary Lunn told Keen that the government had lost confidence in her, but when he appeared before the committee he could not cite one reason for the decision to dump Keen, who was to serve as president until 2010.
The Chalk River reactor, run by Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd., was shut down on Nov. 18 for routine maintenance, but an inspection by the regulatory staff found that mandatory safety upgrades – connecting vital cooling pumps to an emergency power supply that would work even if the area was hit with an earthquake – had not been done.
Related News

Rio Tinto seeking solutions that transform heat from underground mines into electricity
ARIZONA - The world’s second-largest miner, Rio Tinto announced that it is accepting proposals for solutions that transform waste heat from its underground operations into electricity for reuse.
In a press release, the company said this initiative is aimed at drastically reducing greenhouse gas emissions so that it can achieve its goal of becoming carbon neutral by 2050.
Initially, the project would be implemented at the Resolution copper mine in Arizona, which Rio owns together with BHP (ASX, LON: BHP). At this site, massive electrically-driven refrigeration and ventilation systems are in charge of cooling the work environment because of the latent heat…