Court rejects GE challenge to EPA cleanup orders

subscribe

A U.S. appeals court rejected a legal challenge by General Electric Co to the federal Environmental Protection Agency's EPA orders that direct companies to clean up hazardous waste.

The court rejected the company's argument that the law and the way EPA administers it violated constitutional due process rights because the agency issued the orders without a hearing before a neutral decision maker.

The ruling was a setback to GE's long-running effort to overturn a provision of Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act, known as the Superfund law that seeks to ensure that polluters pay for the environmental hazards they created.

At issue were EPA's unilateral administrative orders that direct companies and others to clean up hazardous waste for which they are responsible if the sites pose an imminent and substantial threat to public safety.

Companies that fail to follow the orders can face large fines.

GE had argued that the mere issuance of an order could inflict immediate, serious, and irreparable damage by depressing a company's stock price and increasing its cost of financing.

But the three-judge panel unanimously rejected the company's arguments.

"Such 'consequential' injuries — injuries resulting not from EPA's issuance of the" order "but from market reactions to it — are insufficient to merit" constitutional due process protection, Judge David Tatel wrote in the ruling.

To the extent the regime implicated constitutionally protected property interests by imposing compliance costs and threatening fines and punitive damages, the system satisfied due process because recipients can obtain a hearing by refusing to comply and forcing EPA to sue in federal court, he said.

The appeals court upheld a federal judge's ruling in favor of EPA.

Related News

nb electricity meter

Old meters giving away free electricity to thousands of N.B. households

FREDERICTION - Home and business owners with old power meters in New Brunswick have been getting the equivalent of up to 10 days worth of electricity a year or more for free, a multi million dollar perk that will end quickly if the Energy and Utilities Board approves the adoption of smart meters.

Last week the EUB began deliberations over whether to allow NB Power to purchase and install 360,000 new generation smart meters for its residential and commercial customers as part of a $92 million upgrade of its distribution system.

If approved, that will spell the end to about 98,000 aging…

READ MORE
wind turbines

Cancelling Ontario's wind project could cost over $100M, company warns

READ MORE

clary power lines

Electricity alert ends after Alberta forced to rely on reserves to run grid

READ MORE

nelson charging station

Nelson, B.C. Gets Charged Up on a New EV Fast-Charging Station

READ MORE

bc ferries hybrid ship

BC Ferries celebrates addition of hybrid ships

READ MORE