Greens going against grain with platform

subscribe

If Stephane Dion got the pooping puffin treatment from the juvenile Conservative war room, one can only imagine what bird analogy they have in store for Elizabeth May. Perhaps an albatross hanging around her neck?

Cartoonish caricatures aside, the Green party leaderÂ’s platform, unveiled in Halifax, does seem more of a hindrance to her electability than a help.

The platformÂ’s centrepiece is a $50-a-tonne carbon tax that would hike the price of coal-fired electricity by three cents a kilowatt hour and the price at the pumps by 12 cents a litre.

Nova Scotians briefly got a taste of that kind of sticker shock at the gas station earlier this month as hurricane Ike barrelled into Texas – and they were none too pleased.

On the bright side, the Greens’ carbon tax would rake in $35 billion a year, which would then be used to lower payroll and income taxes. Companies that cut their greenhouse gas emissions would see their corporate taxes lowered by $50 a tonne – that is, if they have taxable profits – and they’d avoid the carbon tax altogether, for a total savings of $100 per tonne.

But the reality is Ms. May is driving further and faster down a path that has already proven virtually impassable for the Liberals.

Polls show their proposed carbon tax, which would also be offset by income tax cuts, has fizzled in Atlantic Canada.

And compared to the Greens, what the Grits are pitching is a Carbon Tax Lite Cola: It would be phased in over four years, maxing out at $40 a tonne, and gasoline would be exempt.

Still, itÂ’s a non-starter for most voters. This is not to say that the thinking behind "green shifting" is without merit.

But even if you accept Ms. MayÂ’s contention that her green plan is merely "a different way of collecting taxes," she opens herself up to attack by advocating a bona fide tax hike on another front. She would put the GST back up one percentage point to fund municipalitiesÂ’ infrastructure projects (although new highway construction would be verboten).

While we agree with most economists that Stephen Harper’s two-point GST cut was the wrong approach – reducing income taxes is more effective, albeit less visible – it remains his most popular policy. It would be easier for Ms. May to run against the Fundy tides than the GST cut.

As well as shuffling the tax system, the Greens would also shift priorities, generously funding social programs and alleviating poverty with a guaranteed annual income.

And if Ms. May had her druthers, pot-smoking would be legal in Canada and poppy-growing legal in Afghanistan – as part of an effort to supply low-cost narcotics to developing countries.

In fact, one of the most abrupt about-faces would be in foreign policy.

Ms. May would redeploy our troops to tamer parts of Afghanistan, allowing them to serve as UN peacekeepers, but not as NATO soldiers. (The NATO mission is also UN-mandated, but the Greens gloss over that point.) How could our NATO allies not view this as a dereliction of duty? What a way to win friends and influence people. As the war is heats up, the Greens would rather Canada stick its head in the sand and pretend it can be won by falling back.

Out with the albatross. In with the ostrich.

Related News

net zero power grid

Can Canada actually produce enough clean electricity to power a net-zero grid by 2050?

TORONTO - By Merran Smith and Mark Zacharias

Canada is an electricity heavyweight. In addition to being the world’s sixth-largest electricity producer and third-largest electricity exporter, Canada can boast an electricity grid that is now 83 per cent emission-free, not to mention residential electricity rates that are the cheapest in the Group of Seven countries.

Indeed, on the face of it, the country’s clean electricity system appears poised for success. With an abundance of sunshine and blustery plains, Alberta and Saskatchewan have wind- and solar-power potential that rivals the best on the continent. Meanwhile, British Columbia, Manitoba, Quebec, and Newfoundland and Labrador…

READ MORE
california wild fire

California Utility Cuts Power to Massive Areas in Northern, Central California

READ MORE

California scorns fossil fuel but can't keep the lights on without it

READ MORE

texas grid improvements

5 ways Texas can improve electricity reliability and save our economy

READ MORE

pg&e logo

PG&E’s Pandemic Response Includes Precautionary Health and Safety Actions; Moratorium on Customer Shutoffs for Nonpayment

READ MORE