Dismiss remaining charges, asks former Westar CEO, strategy officer

subscribe

Lawyers for two former Westar Energy Inc. executives asked a federal judge to dismiss the remaining criminal counts against their clients.

The defense attorneys for former Chief Executive David Wittig and former chief strategy officer Douglas Lake argued before U.S. District Judge Julie Robinson that an appellate court ruling last year effectively prohibited prosecutors from using evidence necessary to charge the two men.

They also said other charges aren't supported by securities laws dealing with public companies.

Wittig and Lake were convicted in 2005 of wire fraud, money laundering, conspiracy and circumvention of internal controls. The charges were tied to a scheme prosecutors claimed was designed to increase the men's compensation at the Topeka-based utility and hide it from regulators and shareholders.

The 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals threw out the convictions in January 2007 and barred prosecutors from retrying Wittig and Lake on the fraud and money laundering charges, saying they hadn't presented enough evidence that the men's actions were criminal.

The two are scheduled to be tried on the remaining conspiracy and circumvention charges on September 9.

Lake attorney Patrick McInerney said that by banning any reference to the fraud and money laundering charges, the appellate court also barred prosecutors from resubmitting much of the evidence that is necessary to prove the two men were part of a conspiracy. To do so, he said, would violate the defendants' constitutional protection against double jeopardy.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Richard Hathaway said it was possible to convict someone of conspiracy even if the defendant isn't convicted of the underlying illegal acts.

The defense attorneys also argued that the two men shouldn't be retried on the circumvention of internal controls, which claim Wittig and Lake intentionally underreported how often they used corporate aircraft for personal trips — which officials consider part of an executive's compensation.

They said that circumvention charges must involve a company's financial documents and that the Securities and Exchange Commission doesn't consider executive pay and benefits are financial.

Robinson, who didn't immediately rule on the motion to dismiss the remaining charges, said she doubted the appellate court would have bothered remanding the case back to district court if no other charges were possible.

"In reading the 10th Circuit's opinion, there's strong language that they meant what they said and they meant for there to be a retrial," she said.

Related News

calgary deep freeze

Alberta sets new electricity usage record during deep freeze

CALGARY - Albertans are cranking up their thermostats and blasting heat into their homes at overwhelmingly high rates as the deep freeze continues. 

It’s so cold that the province set a new all-time record Tuesday evening for electricity usage. 

According to the Alberta Electric System Operator (AESO), 11,729 MW of power was used around 7 p.m. Tuesday, passing the previous record set in January of last year by 31 MW.

Temperatures reached a low of -29 C in Calgary on Tuesday while Edmonton saw a low of -30 C, according to Environment Canada. Wind chill  made it feel closer to -40.

“That increase —…

READ MORE
houston substation

Electric Cooperatives, The Lone Shining Utility Star Of The Texas 2021 Winter Storm

READ MORE

ALBERTA EV

How Alberta’s lithium-laced oil fields can fuel the electric vehicle revolution

READ MORE

alberta electricity meter

Alberta ratepayers on the hook for unpaid gas and electricity bills from utility deferral program

READ MORE

Pennsylvania Clean Energy Employment Report

Clean energy jobs energize Pennsylvania: Clean Energy Employment Report

READ MORE